Investing in Ukraine: Response and Responsibility

Dear Oksana, Jeff is absolutely correct regarding our commitment to invest in Ukraine. With God Almighty as my witness, and to Whom I will eventually answer, no mafia, no corruption, whether at street level or highest levels of government, will compromise our efforts.

You don't know me yet, but possibly you will at some point. For now, I will tell you this, with full assurance that I can back up everything I say, in or out of any honest court of law if necessary: I have resisted corruption in Russia and Ukraine for more than five years now, and I will never stop. I have been poisoned and jailed by Russian FSB, November 1, 2000 to be precise, not only for refusing to pay extortion money in exchange for being allowed to do business in Russia (Tomsk), but also for speaking out against corruption in Russia. I would do the same again without hesitation, except that Russian FSB are very, very afraid of me and will no longer allow me to enter the country. That is the only choice such cowards have in dealing with me. I've told them this before, and I say it again now.

Nevertheless, I left behind a large-scale community development project in Tomskaya Oblast (http://www.ri-tomsk.org) that not even Russian FSB could block or prevent, and even Putin himself eventually supported.

In 2002-3, I proposed a similar project in Crimea, Ukraine ( http://www.p-ced.com/crimea ) US Embassy - Kyiv, represented by Mr. Robert Garverick of the embassy's Economic Section, was quick to get behind the proposed $40 million four-year project. At my request, that project was halted after Crimea's Economy Minister and Deputy Prime Minister required bribes before allowing the proposed project to cross their desks as was required for implementation. The entire process is well-documented in the office of the US Ambassador to Ukraine, US Senate Committee on Intelligence, and to the office of former US Senator John Edwards. In addition, I spoke out in May 2003 in Kyiv Post's editorial section, in an interview on Voice of America-Ukraine (interviewer: Olga Kulish, Washington, DC), and more recently in an interview with International Committee for Crimea ( http://www.iccrimea.org/scholarly/economicdev.html )

As soon as Crimea's Economy Minister and Deputy Prime Minister as of May 2003 are removed from office, I will request continuation of the Crimea project. There is no point in starting it as long as corrupt officials remain in office, and I will never be quiet about them. There is absolutely nothing to be done to silence me except kill me, and I am not afraid to die in the course of resisting corruption and demanding social and economic justice for my beloved Ukrainian brethren. That made me an Orange Revolutionary almost two years ago.

With the advent of the Orange Revolution -- an event I passionately, desperately hoped for and believed was possible from the hearts of Ukrainian people -- I am now preparing to modify the Crimea proposal to include all of Ukraine. I doubt very much that the US side will dare refuse me, because right is right. The case to be made for Ukraine now demands from any and every conceivable moral and/or strategic imperative that what was first suggested in the Crimea proposal now be expanded to all of Ukraine on condition that each and every local level where any implementation occurs is clear and clean of corruption. It's my work, my proposal, and I've said from the start, many times, on the record in many, many nooks and crannies of US government and elsewhere, that I will absolutely enforce copyright protection to prevent its use except in cases where corruption is disallowed. That is my right under Ukrainian, US and International Law.

Now, Ukraine has a president who is also passionately committed to anti-corruption. Here is the very simple solution to corruption: don't do it, don't participate in it. Mafia cannot collect one kopeck from me because I won't pay it. That is precisely what President Yushchenko is wanting of Ukrainian citizens, and I am certain that many millions of Ukrainians are of exactly that same opinion. If extortion is attempted against me, everyone knows what will happen: it won't be a secret, and I don't think new Ukraine's government is prepared to put up with it. It's the same for every person in Ukraine: if you hit corruption, publicize it, speak out, stand up. Nineteen days on Maidan was the start.
Razom! Terry E. Hallman Kharkiv, Ukraine

( categories: Letters )

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Submitted by Jeff.Mowatt on Tue, 2005-04-12 13:17.

Terry,

I hope weve made a clear distinction between national scale economic development objectives and the grassroots efforts that Ukrainians could be making for themselves.

Regarding the former - I know our friends in Maidan and Pora are actively participating in meaningful dialogue, but where are the responses of ordinary citizens that could be developing the latter?

Ill be joining you an May 1st heaving a bulky knitting machine for someone wanting to pull themselves up by the roots, though now. Im concerned that like-minded individuals may be something of a minority.

As I understand it, Prime Minister Julia Tymoshenko has called on the Ukrainian diaspora for initiatives to help Ukraine. So where are their ideas? Certainly none of the groups Ive contacted have anything to say in response, neither have the former Peace Corps volunteers who seemed to be inviting dialogue here not long ago.

Maybe the discussion isnt being held in English? Though Oksana tried and now shes disappeared. OK then, well have to talk amongst ourselves.

Are we moving too fast here I wonder? We might assume that people want an affordable national internet infrastructure as were proposing but will they be able or even willing to make full use of it? We can do our best to lead a horse to water, but can it really be forced to drink?

Regards,

Jeff Mowatt

Submitted by Terry Hallman on Wed, 2005-04-13 00:40.

You and I are long-standing friends, of course, based on our shared compassion and concern for fellow human beings in venues where we can find an honest opportunity to make a positive difference in as many lives as possible. However, my view is largely from ground-level in Russia and Ukraine, and you know as well as anyone the difficulties I've encountered from this end while you've held down the fort in London.


From what I see and FEEL in Ukraine, Ukrainians are mostly very kind, gentle, and truly decent people who are still stunned from such as the sadistic abuses of the Soviet era, not least the Holodomor during Stalin's heyday. Few families in Ukraine were unaffected by Stalin's terror. It's very difficult to relate this to Westerners, even to a close friend such as you are. It's not something that can be expressed so much in words as in just living here and FEELING the culture in Ukraine day-to-day. The only way I can describe it is a lingering feeling of shock, pain, fear, but now with a real, genuine sense of new hope.


President Yushchenko's own father, for example, was a prisoner of Auschwitz, Buchenwald and Dachau. In his statement to joint session of US Congress on April 6, he said "I am a son of a nation that survived the most terrible tragedies of the 20th century, the Holodomor famine that took away 20 million lives of Ukrainians and the Holocaust." ( http://eng.maidanua.org/node/249 )


Given the worst of the worst that our countries -- UK and US -- have had to endure even given 9/11 in the US and Nazi V-1 and V-2 bombings of London and the UK during WW2, our national experiences pale in comparison to the relative percentage of lives lost to terrorism in the Ukrainian Holodomor alone. Thus, neither of us can really feel and fully understand the spiritual weariness of Ukrainians.


Consequently, it comes as little surprise to me that Ukrainians might seem a bit slow on the uptake and understanding of what people like you and I are trying to do solely for the sake of humanity with the borders of Ukraine. Ukrainians have been abused and terrorized for so long, by their own government, such that I think it is inevitable that it will take time, patience, and things as simple as love and commitment -- even though from "foreign" friends -- before Ukrainians can recover from abuses, horrors, and tragedies that you and I cannot truly understand.


I see very, very good people day in and day out who are now hopeful, but the previous pain and struggles from so many years persist in attitude and spirit. By default, that puts people like you and me as leaders in offering hope and direction to Ukrainians at the grassroots level while at the same time lobbying for support at the national level in the hundreds of millions of US dollars. That latter task is now nearing successful completion, due to massive lobbying efforts by many on the US side who have finally come to understand who Ukrainians really are and what the nation of Ukraine is really about.


Suspicion and skepticism about trying to improve life, via foreigners of any nationality, are the norm I see, and which surprises me not at all. Given the ignorance of our own countries' oversight and ignorance of a horror as great as the Ukrainian Holodomor, I can well understand why Ukrainians in their heart and soul are slow on the uptake of anything we might have to offer to improve lives in Ukraine.


What we are attempting will take time, and the greatest of patience before we have any right to hope or expect that we are, or might be, truly friends to Ukrainians. In the end, love will overcome, and I believe that my US compatriots from the US Peace Corps continue to lobby behind-the-scenes for the best interests of Ukrainians whom they have learned to love and respect exactly as I have.


Our efforts are just beginning. Earning respect, trust, and above all genuine love, takes time, patience, and commitment. I am here in Ukraine as long as it takes, and at this point as far as I can see, for the remainder of my life. That's all I can offer on my end, and I hope it might be enough to at least begin to make some real progress towards what I know you and I are both committed to.


Terry
Kharkiv

Submitted by Andriy Morozuk (not verified) on Wed, 2005-04-13 04:21.

Sorry for going off topic:

Dear Terry Hallman & Jeff Mowatt,

I am wondering - just who are you guys? Are you US gov't officials? Or regular guys trying to make a difference? I would honestly like to join you, to help make a difference in my homeland. I currently live in Canada because my parents moved here in search of a better life. I have many ideas on how to get the people moving, and many ideas to develop Ukraine further. I'd be very glad if either you Terry, or Jeff could contact me. I sent an email to T.Hallman@p-ced.com but did not get a reply.

So, Terry or Jeff, please contact me.

E-mail: amorozuk@sympatico.ca

Submitted by Terry Hallman on Fri, 2005-04-15 14:23.

Andriy,
I assure you I am NOT a US government official, nor an official of any other government. I am far too outspoken. If anything, I've contributed to quite a few grey hairs among US government officials over the years, due to my very independent and assertive stance as a US citizen. But that is just as democracy should be: freedom to speak out, even causing grey hair among my beloved (sometimes) government representatives.


Jeff and I are friends. He is a Brit, for which I have long since forgiven him after a bit of a war starting in 1776 and even after Brits went to the trouble to burn down the US White House circa 1812 during Madison's presidency (and which many of us in the US still haven't forgotten, even though it's now almost 200 years ago.)


I don't know why your email to the address you mentioned didn't go through. I'll check it. Otherwise, you can also use webconsult_2000@yahoo.com or newswire@yahoo.com .


Regards,
Terry E. Hallman
Kharkiv, Ukraine

Submitted by Jeff.Mowatt on Thu, 2005-04-14 21:05.

Not at all Andriy, I've just mailed you with all our secrets. Everyone else has to keep guessing.

Jeff

Submitted by Oksana (not verified) on Mon, 2005-04-11 23:09.

Dear Terry,
It is so very wonderful to have read your response which your wrote with such passion. Your name sounds familiar to me. I stand to be corrected, but are you married to an Ukrainian and you are of Anglo-American background? I am so sorry that you went through such horrors as being poisoned. According to my Canadian connections (I'm from Canada), I was told to wait when it comes to investing in Ukraine. I know there are many Ukrainians who have successfully invested in Ukraine and one example is President Yushchenko's in-laws from Chicago. I spoke to my financial adviser a couple of days ago and he said to wait. Perhaps I shall look into doing something small at first but I must visit Ukraine to look around. God willing, I hope to travel to Ukraine in August.
You know very well that big companies are not ready to jump into investing in Ukraine. I hear there is high inflation in Ukraine. Look at Georgia. After 2 years, there is no growth.
How does one get in contact with you? I would prefer that this e-mail does not get printed on the website of Maidan.
There is a group of people leaving May 8 for Kyiv from Toronto. One of them is the Mayor of Toronto, Mr. Miller and also a councillor, Ms. Luby plus some business people.
God bless you and keep you safe.
Respectfully,
Oksana

Submitted by Terry Hallman on Sat, 2005-04-16 02:27.

Oksana,

Please forgive my delay in responding.  I have been back and forth between Kharkiv and Kyiv during this past week, or preparing for back-and-forth to Kyiv.  Things are happening very quickly now in Ukraine, as Im sure you probably understand.  I beg you forbearance,  and truly appreciate your kind remarks.  I will answer your questions, and concerns, in serial order.


Im more Germanic/American background than Anglo/American.  I also have Anglo/Irish blood, but that's as close as I come to Anglo.


Should the time ever arrive that a nice Ukrainian girl is brave enough to deal with my life on a daily basis without too much worry, I would be delighted to have a Ukrainian wife.  My being the political animal that I am, marriage to a nice Ukrainian girl who has the strength to deal with my unrelenting assertiveness (and thats putting it mildly) toward freedom and human decency would be for me a private gift from God.  


Ive done as much as I can for Russia.  I understand that FSB does not take kindly to anyone doing things for Russian citizens to make the lives of ordinary Russian citizens better.  Nothing has changed since Chekist/NKVD/KGB days in that regard.  People like me dont fit in regardless of nationality, but with a US passport Im not so easily shot, imprisoned, or disappeared.  So be it.  I will never shut up, and that alone drives half of FSB crazy while encouraging the other half.  


In Ukraine, it encourages seventy percent of SBU (my estimate, which Im willing to discuss once again with SBU over beer and a good meal as long as theyre paying), and irritates the remainder.  The (Russian) woman I loved most recently was once an FSB agent, but she couldnt get anything past me.  So now were apart, I remain single, and now insist even to God on a Ukrainian wife.


I hope that answers that part of questions.


Next, regarding investing in Ukraine, for the moment I agree with your advisors. This is the time to let things settle down and stabilize a bit.  Ukraine is in the midst of an extraordinary transition, the likes of which the modern world has rarely seen.  I daresay that almost nobody on earth knows what to make of what just happened in Ukraine via the Orange Revolution.  To me, even now, having been here through all of it and encouraging it on a strictly personal level quite some time before it came to pass, Ukraines revolution stands in my mind as one of the rarest of miracles.  While in Kharkivs tent camp, local militsia and SBU both questioned me as to why I was there.  I told them that I was watching history in the making, and they understood.  They not only did not give me any problems, they also made sure that I was absolutely safe and protected.  They knew and I knew and everyone in the tent camp knew what was going on and why I was there and why ALL of us were there (on the Orange side, at least) : solidarity among people insisting on honesty and freedom with the same passion in all of our souls.  It made no difference where we were born, most in Ukraine and me in the US.  We ALL understood, and stood shoulder to shoulder, arm in arm and hand in hand.  It was during that time that I knew I would take a Ukrainian wife, and no other, at some point if ever.  


It was just after that time that I grasped the new investment potential in Ukraine: give things a little time to settle down and stabilize, start small and grow.  I am certain that Ukraine will prove to be among the very best investment climates in the world.  I say this from very, very hard work, careful examination, tough experience, and with abiding, passionate love FROM most Ukrainians along the way excluding former government entities in general, and government entities in the Autonomous Republic of Crimea in particular.  


I respectfully suggest that if Kyiv continues to ignore ARC, problems such as the recent Russian naval invasion of Feodosia will not only increase but will also become routine policy of Russia toward Crimea and where possible upward to the rest of Ukraine, eastern flank first.  I know how Russian foreign policy thinking is going in Kremlins near-abroad hopes, and I know extremely well who controls it: Russian FSB.  At such time as this threat is effectively and finally countered and stopped, Ukraine will then become a safe investment climate with predictable, reliable investment calculations heading full speed to solid European integration.  Kremlin will remain quite active in trying to prevent that because Russia (Moscow) cannot qualify until such questions as Ryazan are finally and clearly answered once and for all.  Kremlin believes the Ryazan question has quietly disappeared.  


It has not.  


Until the time that Ukraine fully shakes off Russian provocation (and US hegemony, to be clear and fair), I must agree with your investment advisors: be very careful, start small and do litmus testing, and look to grow your investments on that basis.  


Regarding growth in Georgia, take one guess as to who is actively impeding and interfering in Georgias new democracy despite Georgias increasing insistence that they get their military bases OUT of Georgia, so far to no avail.


Kremlin has not surrendered its near-abroad policy, nor its hopes for continuation of CIS, nor its provocation in northern Georgia, nor its provocation on the north-eastern slice of Moldova.  I say this will full awareness and acknowledgment of my own governments adventurous hegemony in this same region of the world.  


And I say this: Ukraine is Ukraine, and Ukraine has clearly demonstrated beyond any doubt that she is neither US nor Russian.  Once both of those sides are gently pressed clear to that understanding, then Ukraine will emerge and manifest her enormous economic, political, social and above all, spiritual potential.


We are watching a miracle continuing, a miracle in the making, Oksana.  I believe we should consider ourselves very, very fortunate even to be aware of it.  Patience is the watchword for investment, with due caution, but also with due hope.  Ive already bet my life on that.


With very best wishes and regards,


Terry Hallman

Kharkiv, Ukraine

 

 

 

Submitted by Terry Hallman on Sat, 2005-04-16 02:04.

(Sorry -- somehow posted twice. Removed one copy...
T.H.)